Clary Sage Organics

The Beige Report: Organic Period Panties?

-

There’s a lot of gorgeous fashion out there that’s eco-friendly these days. All you have to do is take a quick scroll of our fashion section to learn about dozens upon dozens of designers pushing sustainability up onto the catwalk and out into the stores. But occasionally, the green goes beige and things take a turn for crunchy town. Granolaville. The ’70s.

Introducing The Beige Report, where we cover the well-meaning, but unfortunate attempts of eco brands with the best of intentions and the not-so-best of products. First honors: organic period panties.

You know, I remember when I first got my period. It actually happened twice.

The first time was a ploy to convince my faster-developing friends that I had in fact become a woman. I did this by carrying around paper thin panti-liners in a Ziploc bag in my Bermuda Bag and telling them I’d be right back because, like, “I have to change my pad!”

The second time it was real and Mom, a properly embarrassed Catholic, gave me a jumbo plastic sack of the biggest maxi-pads ever created. You know the kind, ladies: you became uni-butt and boys looked at you funny because they couldn’t quite understand what was wrong with your derriere.

Now, you can reclaim your overly padded youth organically with Organic Period Panties by Lunapads!

-
If only I’d had these pads back in the day. I could’ve chosen from bikini, thong, hipsters or briefs and when the pad was, um, full, I would’ve pulled it out of my matching organic panties, stored it in yet another Ziploc bag until I got home, then washed them by hand!

Oh Lunapads, I don’t know what I think of you except that you remind me no matter what I do come period time it’s eco-unfriendly. I still have to consider menstruating on a monthly basis and that it causes a big footprint, but is this my only choice? This and a Diva Cup?

Maybe we should start taking into consideration Native American culture, where women retreated to a menstrual hut once a month and shot the breeze with other women on their cycle. Hornets in a jar!

From bad green design to ridiculous marketing campaigns, find out what peeves the writers and editors of EcoSalon in our team column, The Beige Report.


Subscribe

DISCUSSION

  • Sarah
    May 3rd, 2010 at 4:20 PM

    I’m sorry, but how could cute, incredibly comfortable, organic panties possibly be designated as ‘beige’? Eliminating wasteful and unhealthy menstrual products from my life is hardly granolaville – it’s simple good sense. Between my diva cup & lunapanties I no longer thing of my monthly cycle as something to deal with – I enjoy absolute comfort, no leaking, significant cost savings, and oh yea – i’m being eco-conscious too.

    You goofed on this one, ecosalon.

  • Sharna
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:02 PM

    Wow. I love Lunapads and the Divacup. I enjoy my period (apart from exhaustion and cramps) now.
    Maybe it isnt for you, that doesnt make it something that is bad. Alot of women i have spoken to have felt so much more comfortable with themselves and their body by using a cup or cloth pads.
    Also, luna panties? I much prefer them over the old system i had of keeping my worst pairs of undies around for when i had my cycle. We are allowed to feel cute and comfortable even on our period!

  • Meagan
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:05 PM

    Uhm, yea… It may not be the ‘coolest’ thing around, but it is amazing! My comfort level around that time of the month has improved so much that it out weighs the hand cleaning. Plus it is good for the environment no matter how small the effect. Although hiding in a hut for a week with my friends sounds like a lot of fun!!

  • Tara M
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:07 PM

    Not to mention that it’s been proven that you have lighter periods when using cloth pads! So not only am I eco-conscious…it’s safer for my body!!

    I personally really like the idea of having panties specially designed to hold my Luna-pads. Beats wrecking all my other panties, leaking thru a pad that is hurting the environment and my body.

    I agree – you goofed on this one!

  • Dee
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:07 PM

    Have you ever tried them? I know the idea is weird, but I got hooked… They are soooo comfy you don’t feel like you’re wearing anything, and all you do is wash them like laundry and you never have to buy crinkly plastic sweaty crap from the store ever again. It’s not really a new concept, nor is it weird once you get used to it. I feel AWESOME for using them.. I love it.

  • Lisa @Retro Housewife Goes Green
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:13 PM

    Um what? This is super green and I own luna pads and the panties! I’m wearing one of their pads now and they are a 100 times better than the plastic ones. I LOVE them! So soft. The panties are so great I wear them without a liner all the time, period or not.

  • Pacific
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:14 PM

    Yeah… I gotta agree with Sarah. Lunapads has made my period experience be 100 times more comfortable than it ever was before. After using disposable products for 13 years, I made the switch to the DivaCup and Lunapads. The Lunapanties are a dream. So comfortable. With the DivaCup, I have never felt more “clean” during my period–I never wake up to bloody sheets, I never notice a smell. It’s the ultimate way to be in touch with your body during your period. I never dread my period anymore. I am never uncomfortable, unless it’s from cramps or headaches. My feminine hygiene products are never the cause. I could never say that about tampons or pads. I hate the feel of sticky diapers in the morning. Soft felt fabric, cute designs, the ability to wash and wear–I love my Lunapads and Lunapanties. They are anything but Beige.

  • Ashleigh
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:18 PM

    I agree with Sarah, bad decision. Have you even tried them?

    Honestly, the DivaCup is the best thing I’ve ever used for my period! I don’t even think about my period anymore, nor do I dread getting it every month anymore (like Sarah). LunaPads are cute, easy to use, and extremely comfortable. In a world full of excess LunaPads and the DivaCup are Godsends.

    Don’t knock ‘em till ya try ‘em! :)

  • Melissa
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:23 PM

    There are hundreds of women out there who are fine with making the very easy and comfortable switch to reusable pads or menstrual cups. Instead of devaluing something you can’t understand, why not say “here is a green option that is catching on, but its just not for me”. Or, give it the ol’ college try and see if you don’t see the light.

  • YW
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:25 PM

    Sorry, but I have to agree with Sarah. I don’t find Lunapads products “granolaville” at all. Nor do I consider my period a blight to the environment. What’s so wrong with reusable pads? You can buy very cute, stylish travel purses to put those “um, full” pads in (no wasteful Ziplocs necessary) until you can get home and wash them.

    I love my Lunapads, and my Diva Cup. I can’t imagine how I got through my periods before I found these wonderful, eco-friendly products!

  • Tia
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:26 PM

    I agree with Sarah. While normally your site is great, this is a major biff. I calculate that my savings are over 700$ a year and the Lunapads are actually comfortable to wear. It’s a shame you feel this way about a really great product that it sounds like you didn’t even try before bashing.

  • Sheriagogo
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:33 PM

    So sad you missed the point! Luna-pads are an amazing product and Luna-panties are a helpful extension of the entire product line. I have a couple of thongs that I use on the tail ends of my period when I have Yoga class. You know – when you are too light for a tampon (er, DIVA CUP) but you still need a liner (just in case!). I doubt any of us die-hard Luna-pad users wear exclusively luna-panties – but one or two pairs come in handy now and then!!

    It’s called ‘thinking outside the box’ – the whole point of being eco-conscious!!

  • Casey
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:33 PM

    Cloth and reusable menstrual product may not be for everyone; how ever that doesn’t make them any less green. I personally made the switch over two years ago. I no longer have to deal with hot, sticky, crinkly, noisy pads. Instead I have soft, pretty, breathable, quiet pads that I can change in a public rest room with no one the wiser. I will not have to buy another pad for many years to come. Yes I own Luna panties (and a good number of other cloth menstrual products) I love them. I only have one liner that matches the rest are different colours. And I machine wash them in a cold wash with my other cold wash clothing so no I’m not using extra water just for washing them either. I’m guessing that what this is really about is that you are uncomfortable with the idea of carrying around those soiled pads and possibly the washing too. That doesn’t diminish how wonderful cloth menstrual products are for those of us who don’t have issues with it.

  • Jane
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:34 PM

    Forget being eco-friendly for a moment….

    …these options are healthier and more hygienic than disposable options as they don’t encourage bacterial growth, they’re breathable, and don’t contain potentially harmful chemicals. So less odour, less risk of allergic reactions, and less risk of infections such as thrush, bacterial vaginosis and UTI’s – they’re specifically recommended by doctors and nurses for this reason.

    They’re breathable and soft material so no feeling sweaty or wet like with disposables, no gathering up, no sticking to your skin or hair, and no rubbing on your legs. They’re no more effort than just putting them in the washing machine – verses disposables which smell after you’ve thrown them in a waste bin to decompose next to the toilet, or having to wrap them up and carry smelly disposables in your purse when there’s no bin.

    Divacups not only don’t dry-out, prevent vaginal cleaning, encourage bacterial growth, keep vagina exposed to pH altering flow, lose fibres, or contain chemicals, but because of this there’s less risk of infections and no known risk of TSS or long-term health risks. This means they can be worn for 12 hours form light to heavy flow, overnight, before menstruation, and no need to alternate with pads. Cups are thus far more convenient, they also don’t leak like tampons or pads, and can even lessen flow and cramps.

    So, as well as being eco-friendly on many different levels they are fashionable – didn’t disposable companies make a big deal about thong liners and black liners? Well, Lunapads win a few hundred times over on that one! They’re also body-positive (happy periods!), economical, healthy, hygienic, comfortable, convenient, reliable…so why so down on such products? Have you even tried them?

    These options have been around for a long time and are becoming HUGELY popular with women again for many reasons – so much for “not-so-best of products”!

  • Kris
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:36 PM

    I second what Sarah said! I know it sounds weird at first (it took me awhile), but I am *never* going back. I don’t have to shove bleached cotton made by corporate America up my…ahem…my dog does not dig these out of the garbage and chew them up, and they are soooo comfy! Forget environmentally friendly…I don’t do anything for the environment that is incovenient for me, and my Diva cup and Lunapads are easier than the alternative…by far.

    Try it before you criticize it, ecosalon.

  • Catherine
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:39 PM

    Have you tried either the Diva Cup or any cloth pads? They are actually better and more comfortable, as well as greener and more cost effective than disposable menstrual products.

    And thong-shaped cloth pads exist, too. There’s really something for everyone.

  • Catherine
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:42 PM

    While I haven’t bought lunapanties just yet, I have used lunapads and they are great. I think for anyone with an annoying discharge or spotting that lunapanties would be great which is why I want a pair. You don’t have to change a ton of pads, you can just change the liner…a lot of women us them just at home so you don’t have to carry used liners in a ziploc bag…which is also why they sell wetbags for used pads.

    With the right facts we can all use lunapanties with comfort and happiness!

  • Eliza
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:44 PM

    I’m totally with Sarah on this one. No tampons and pads going into landfills. No bleached cotton taking away not just my menstrual flow, but fluids that are supposed to stay in my body. No monthly expense. No scratchy paper products ‘down there’. Total comfort. And the red lunapanties are downright sexy.

  • Tasha
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:47 PM

    retreating to a menstrual hut? really? have you even tried the diva cup and/or a lunapad? it doesn’t sound like it. because if you did you’d likely being singing a different tune.
    i was period free for almost 2 years after getting pregnant. when i first got it back (just recently), i forgot how much i hated using pads and/or tampons… not to mention how uncomfortable it was! on my second day, i went straight to the store and bought a diva cup.
    i was way more comfortable; didn’t fear anything leaking; not to mention the incredible amounts of money i will be saving! plus there are no chemicals to further mess with my body. and that’s not even mentioning the environment…

  • Kaekae
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:53 PM

    Speaking for other benefits because it is obvious that reducing disposables and reusing things in general is good thing, but Luna Pads are great. (I don’t have the panties yet). They are pretty, convenient & comfortable (once you get used to the idea), and are saving me money.
    I love pretty things, so having pretty pads is nice. You have to see the pads to appreciate them. I would like to buy one or 2 of the new patterns, but I don’t need them since I have enough for the month with some leftover.
    Are they as thin as an ultra-thin pad, no (well the pad itself is, but I always add a liner or 2), but they much more comfortable and I will never again have to search my bathroom cabinet for a stray pad until I can get to the store.
    Granted, LunaPads aren’t cheap, but since I don’t have to buy stuff every month I am sure I have recovered the initial cost. I would go through about 1 and half boxes a month. That adds up to a lot of money. It doesn’t hurt that I don’t need to replace my liners as frequently as I would a disposable pad (not sure why). With regular pads I was replacing them 4 – 6 times a day, a LunaPad with double liner will last me about 12 hours for all but one day of my period. I do keep extra liners handy at work just in case, but I rarely need them.
    BTW – it really isn’t as gross at it seems.

  • Comfy VeeJayJay
    May 3rd, 2010 at 5:58 PM

    Um, have you actually tried either product? I <3 both for soooo many reasons and frankly, I don't give a rodents fart if they're purty.

    The pads are so much more comfortable and cooshy than putting questionable plastic products next to my ladybits. Fleece = happy. Plastic = rash. And their not much thicker than the slim ones.

    And the Diva Cup? Changed.my.period. For-evs. Why on earth would you put chemically treated paper products INSIDE you? Eweewewwww. No thanks.

    Oh, and granola is healthy and delish. Get a clue.

  • Vancouverite
    May 3rd, 2010 at 6:04 PM

    Yep, I agree with Sarah. LOVE my Lunapanties and the Divacup. Pads were bulky and bad to me in part because of all that plastic crap, like a sad wee bulky diaper.
    I only use my Lunapanties with the Divacup, but I use Lunapads too. I was dared to try them and was shocked at how much I *love* ‘em. They’re comfortable, easy, and they’ve changed my outlook on the whole time o’ the month experience. Frankly, I’m usually surprised, now, when it’s over.

  • Brooke
    May 3rd, 2010 at 6:10 PM

    I must say I agree with Sarah, my luna pads and panties have made my periods a lot more comfortable, no more plastic pants feeling or accidents. I am sorry but I think you missed this one. Give them a try you will be convinced too.

  • Morgan
    May 3rd, 2010 at 6:16 PM

    Oh, please! Do you know how much more comfortable and easier to use resuable, washable cotton pads are? I love my LunaPads, and I’m pretty ordinary!

  • Deb Jung
    May 3rd, 2010 at 6:20 PM

    I’ve been a cloth pad fan for nearly 20 years. Don’t knock them until you’ve tried them! They’re more comfortable than paper and plastic ones and they don’t add to our landfill problems. Using cloth pads is a more ecologically sustainable solution than disposable pads. Fashion is less important than one’s ethics and values.

  • Alden
    May 3rd, 2010 at 6:23 PM

    I would chafe against saving a pad to wash later. But I have no problem with using a luna cup. I actually find it waaay more effective than regular tamps. And it’s saving me a lot of money too!

  • Sara O'
    May 3rd, 2010 at 6:31 PM

    What??? You’re kidding right? I love my Lunapads AND my Diva cup. NOTHING protects better than a diva cup and a thin luna liner. Seriously, you couldn’t pay me to use anything else. And if it does happen to slip out of my bag, no one has a clue what it is but wanna see ‘that cute fabric’!

    Nope, can’t say I agree here. Lunapads is where it’s at.

  • Lindsey
    May 3rd, 2010 at 6:49 PM

    Ewwww, menstruation! I can’t BELIEVE women would want to get in touch with their nasty bodies and wear comfy cotton panties when they could wear bleached, chafing plastic instead! Or even, better–toxic shock! I LOVE toxic shock!

    Come on, Salon. Read “Our Bodies, Our Selves”, go howl at the moon, and quit hating on reusable period products. Rock on, Lunapads!

  • Aaryn
    May 3rd, 2010 at 6:52 PM

    I really don’t think it’s as uncool as you’re making it out to be. Lunapads feel SO much more comfortable than disposable pads. Washing my lunapads and seeing my blood has actually made me feel closer to my body. And really? You’re going to slam on divacups? There have been no recorded cases of TSS while using a menstrual cup, it can stay in for up to 12 hours, and it’s just as convenient as a tampon without the waste and hazardous health risks.

    If these alternatives aren’t good enough, then what else is there that’s ecologically sound and convenient and comfortable? (which are adjectives I would personally use to describe lunapads and the divacup)

  • Amanda
    May 3rd, 2010 at 7:14 PM

    I think this may be a case of “don’t knock it till you try it” After my first month with Lunapads I’ll never go back to disposables!

  • Annie
    May 3rd, 2010 at 7:17 PM

    I would like to hear if the author of this article actually had tried any of these products herself. As a two year user of lunapads, lunapanites and the diva cup, I couldn’t disagree more with you. It’s not about guilt, it’s about feeling better. I would never, ever go back to disposable pads and tampons, even if you bribed me.

  • Dorothy
    May 3rd, 2010 at 7:28 PM

    Dear Amy: If you’re going to pass judgement on a product, you should understand it and try it out first. You clearly don’t know what it’s like to use the panties or the pads, and your rant of preconceptions may be entertaining to some (you are in entertainment, not journalism, correct?)… but is helpful to nobody. Do some research before you spew your word vomit.

  • Sara Ost
    May 3rd, 2010 at 7:30 PM

    Looks like we hit a nerve! Lindsey, no one here thinks menstruation is eww gross. Just because someone isn’t into reusable period products doesn’t mean she’s got a problem with having her period in general. It’s fantastic if people like lunapads and/or diva cups. This is just one eco woman who doesn’t – that doesn’t mean she’s got a problem with her body! :) I think it’s great that different people like different things, personally. I for one have tried the Diva Cup and found it to be a hassle – and it’s not about being squeamish. It’s what feels right for me. As for panties, I don’t like wearing pads in general, so I doubt I’d want to try these out. That’s just me.

    There are actually decent unbleached products out there, but they can be difficult to find (easy to order online though). To each her own!

  • sarah
    May 3rd, 2010 at 7:38 PM

    Dear Sara,

    Your image of the panties as bulky is all wrong. The basic panties have a very lightly padded crotch and some soft straps that can hold a heavier pad in place should it be needed. I find with the Diva Cup that I only need to use a pad in them for my heaviest night of bleeding. The panties offer a basic layer of protection for daily use that is so comfortable that i wear them every day of the year.

    I bought one pair on a lark, and will never go back to any other brand…

  • Martha
    May 3rd, 2010 at 7:41 PM

    Gonna have to agree that this review is way off. The Diva Cup (yes, it is amazing!) and Lunapads have totally changed the way I think about my impact on the environment. Seriously, how many tons of tampons and pads get thrown away? To act as if a reusable pad is gross seems a bit off base. They are just as comfortable (more so I’d say) than disposables, and you just wash them- like you wash clothes, socks, etc. You know, things that get dirty. :) I don’t throw away every pair of panties that get blood on them, I wash them. This seems a logical extension of that “re-use” idea. :) I say, try ‘em out and see if reusable products don’t just change your mind completely!

  • Becky
    May 3rd, 2010 at 7:41 PM

    I echo Annie’s question. Reusables really shouldn’t be knocked until you’ve actually tried them. Cloth pads are WAY more comfortable than the disposable kind– so much so that I, a former tampons-only kind of girl, pretty much only use lunapanties nowadays.

    For me, it’s a win-win. More comfortable, less money, less waste.

    Food for thought.

  • Nikiah
    May 3rd, 2010 at 8:31 PM

    Yup- I am with Sarah on this one–there is nothing “beige” about the Lunapanties.
    They are neither “unforgettable” nor a mere “attempt” at being eco friendly–they simply ARE eco friendly-end of story!

    The women who run this triple bottom line company, are as real as they come, AND they still manage to be successful in business–just liking granola does not make you one….

  • Catherine
    May 3rd, 2010 at 8:34 PM

    Not being into reusable products is just plain ignorant. Who cares if you can buy unbleached anymore…there are still chemical and processing that were done to make those ‘eco friendly’ pads.

    Try the panties or pads or diva cup, then write us another blurb.

  • Sara Ost
    May 3rd, 2010 at 8:35 PM

    Hey Sarah, apologies if this is TMI territory but it’s not just the padding I don’t like. I don’t like the feeling of blood on my skin all day. It’s uncomfortable. That’s just me, though.

  • Sara Ost
    May 3rd, 2010 at 8:38 PM

    (P.S. Catherine, of course even unbleached products have some environmental impact. But I’m not ignorant simply because I don’t share your same preference! I’m different from you. I have different preferences. That’s not ignorance, that’s individual.)

  • Sara Ost
    May 3rd, 2010 at 8:40 PM

    And Becky, Martha, great comments, thanks for sharing your point of view!

  • Nicole Barrette
    May 3rd, 2010 at 8:55 PM

    It bothers me the most that because you don`t like the product you are questioning it`s eco-friendliness. Lunapads and the DivaCup are IMO both amazing products, obviously you don`t agree, but you really think they`re beige??

  • Libby
    May 3rd, 2010 at 8:57 PM

    Writers and especially bloggers have a job of stating their opinion and getting people involved in a discussion – Amy did exceptionally well at both by choosing this topic and taking that stance. This isn’t news, it’s opinion, and she’s allowed to have hers.

    Not everyone agrees, but that’s for us as individuals to decide what’s best for us. Personally, I love my Luna Pads, and even go the “ancient” route of going “on the rag” at night. (Dark colored wash cloths and mens boxer briefs are awesome and super reusable.)

    I do recommend that everyone who thinks they’re “green” try at least one of the Lunapads products – there’s a lot of options and something for everyone. Even if you don’t completely replace your stock of disposables, taking little steps towards reusables helps.

  • Nay-nay
    May 3rd, 2010 at 9:13 PM

    I love, love, love Luna pads and the Diva cup! I really enjoyed reading all these comments. And yes we are all different and entitled to our own opinions but also common sense should prevail. I really think these kind of products are progress and the way of the future. We can’t keep using things that are made in our unsustainable society. we have got so far away from knowing how to look after ourselves some really wouldn’t know what to do if shops were closed even 1 day! I think using these products are steps closer in looking after ourselves if the worst should happen and society stops functioning because of some kind of catastrophe natural or otherwise. :-)

  • Cate
    May 3rd, 2010 at 9:28 PM

    I too am curious as to whether or not the author actually tried either product or just looked at them, got squicked out and said “no way, too weird.” I personally love both lunapads products and the divacup. No more sticky, uncomfortable plasticky pads or tampons that either leaked or were too drying. Never had a problem with any uni-butt syndrome, never have to worry about running out, and I just pop the soiled ones into the washing machine with a regular load of laundry. I think the reason this article touches a nerve with those of us who appreciate lunapanties/lunapads is because it doesn’t come across as one woman’s opinion that reusable don’t work for her. The whole concept is labeled as unfortunate and a “not so best product” at the beginning of the article. So it kinda sounds like you think that those of us who embrace it are bit unfortunate.

  • Dani
    May 3rd, 2010 at 9:32 PM

    Wow, that’s a really bad slippery slope: from bleached, hard tampons and pads to a menstrual hut? I like my body dioxin free, thanks. I made the switch to cloth a few months ago. I will NEVER go back. They are so comfortable, easy to use, and cheap! You should try out this product before bashing it. You might be singing a different tune afterward. Personally, I’d rather take the hut over paper napkins any day.

  • Lindsey
    May 3rd, 2010 at 10:35 PM

    Sara,
    Rereading my comment, I have to wince. No offense intended–I guess it’s the PMS ;P That and one too many instances of icky icky body shaming in my past. I agree–to each her own. :)

  • Lauren
    May 3rd, 2010 at 10:40 PM

    I pretty much lost all inclination to believe this article was an honest piece of journalism when they likened using alternative menstrual products to menstrual huts. Seriously. These products are wonderful, and using them helps you have a healthy relationship with your body instead of hating something that happens to most of us every month. We already learn to hate our bodies enough from the media, what is wrong with reclaiming the one thing that is inherently female, and using products that are super comfortable?

  • Drea
    May 3rd, 2010 at 11:47 PM

    “This blogger obviously didn’t try the products before she tried them”
    oops- I meant before she wrote about them… and I obviously didn’t proof read my response before I posted it! :)

  • Amy DuFault
    May 4th, 2010 at 5:57 AM

    Woohoo! Went off to enjoy life for a night and came back to all your comments-wow.
    My favorite was Dorothy’s love of my “word vomit.”
    Really? Come on Dorothy.
    Get ready for TMI.

    Most of you are right that I have never tried either panties or cup but memories come flooding back of friends I have had through the years who used similar products and quite frankly smelled fishy which as a professional woman out and about I don’t want to deal with.

    Because we DON’T have menstrual huts to escape to it is either these eco choices or the unbleached cotton tampons I prefer to use and instead of pads, now wrap 100% recycled toilet paper around my undies.
    I am 39 and I am suffering from horrifying periods suddenly, where the cup would surely overflow if I were to use. It seems logical for you women who are light bleeders but I’m thinking for women that have heavier flows, this might not be an option. I could be wrong. I’m not opposed to trying and if I do I promise to re-write about my menstrual epiphany.

    Please don’t think I am hating on eco-options, this one just doesn’t fit my style.
    Thanks to Libby who realized I can have my own opinion and that this absolutely isn’t a hot news item (though most of you act as if it is). If you believe I have that much sway in the eco-community than right on.

    Be sure to read my newsy pieces with as much fervor!

  • Chelsea
    May 4th, 2010 at 6:44 AM

    As a woman who has extremely heavy periods and always has I can tell you that you are wrong on these not working for women with heavy flows. At risk of TMI with the Diva Cup and my lunapanties combo I can get away most days with changing the cup the recommend 2x/day. On a bad day it’s 4x/day. Certainly much better than my pre Diva Cup Lunapanties adventures of wearing my darkest pants and dashing to the toilet every hour. As for hand washing? You certainly could–myself I go the lazy route and toss em in the washer with the sheets and towels. Much more convenient than the old it’s 3am I just started my period and I don’t have a single pad/tampon in the house days.

    If your opinion had been hey I tried this it didn’t work for me but maybe it’s for some of you there wouldn’t be such objections to your opinion. There is no need though to bash a fun, cute, eco-friendly, and health friendly product that works for thousands of women because it isn’t for you especially when you’ve never tried it.

  • Katherine Butler
    May 4th, 2010 at 9:47 AM

    Team Amy.

  • Morgan
    May 4th, 2010 at 10:21 AM

    Hi Amy,
    Just wanted to comment on using the DivaCup for heavy flow. It’s actually the ideal product for this situation. The cup holds much more than your average tampon or pad so you are able to leave it in for longer than you would with a disposable product. When it gets full you just empty it and re-insert, it’s not like you just leave it in ALL day and hope for the best.

  • suzanne (aka Lunagal)
    May 4th, 2010 at 10:24 AM

    Amy, woohoo is exactly my feeling right now. Thank you for your post, sharing your opinion and providing a platform for healthy discussion.

    The gals at Lunapads have spent almost 2 decades talking to women about their periods. We are under no illusions that our products are suitable or will work for everyone. Every woman has her own experience and preferences, which are all totally valid.

    I love it that you’ve created the “Beige Report” as it seems like a great way to call out products that greenwash or fail to work . But Lunapanties don’t deserve that label. Surely you have a pair of period panties in the back of your drawers? Why not own a pair of organic cotton period panties that are comfortable, stylish and functional? As for how the products perform with respect to heavy flow, it is possible they might not work for you, but we think you’ll be pleasantly surprised!

    We are thrilled that you are open to trying our some of our products and we’ll be in touch to send you some ASAP. We look forward to your follow up piece!

  • Sara Ost
    May 4th, 2010 at 10:59 AM

    Amy’s editor stepping in for a quick comment. First – aside from a few insulting comments I’ve deleted because they were hateful or hostile – I’m thrilled to see all the great discussion going on here.

    Second, clarification on “beige” – we are not at all saying this is greenwash or that Lunapads aren’t a truly green company. I came up with “The Beige Report” title, and what I had in mind was “blah” beige, not not-green. I can see now how this might be confusing! It’s a reflection on the style factor as an individual perceives it, not the sustainability factor on the whole. And yes, that’s 100% a matter of opinion. News it’s not! I believe firmly that our readers know the difference between traditional news reporting and opinion meant to engage and encourage some healthy debate.

  • Elly D.
    May 4th, 2010 at 12:09 PM

    WOW: Now that’s alot of dialogue on a difference of opinion, on a product that wasn’t checked out, from a person who voiced her opinion on her own menstrual perception.

    Now girls, I would be questioning the name LUNAPADS (I read LOONEY in that) Now I know, having a period sure did take it’s toll on me emotionally but I would prefer a better name like PUREPADS or STEALTHPADS. I would feel empowered and protected.

    Then there is DIVA CUP. Not a bad choice. For what a woman has to endure each month DIVA is an A + title.

    Good God, MENSTRUAL HUT, that could have it’s good points and bad points. Good if IT were the Marriott with room service and a masseuse with a sense of humor and thick skin able to avert the MRS HYDE AND MR JECKYLE

    Now, being very glad to be past menopause and definitely not missing my monthly curse, I was wondering what could be done for a 65 year old woman that has a water leakage problem caused by a bladder that won’t quit and has a mind of it’s own. Yup! Tried the meds. Forget it, the side effects are not acceptable. There is a medical procedure, too risky.
    So, Im thinking are there any LEAKY DIVA-CUPS. THIS IS NOT A JOKE.
    KEEP ME POSTED.
    POISE PADS ARE UNCOMFORTABLE.

  • sarah
    May 4th, 2010 at 12:14 PM

    Elly,

    I hear you on the bladder front – I’ve also found lunapanties to be a godsend for the occasional bladder leaks thanks to my years of childbearing. I suppose i could also do more kegels…

    oooh…i like stealthpads

  • Heidi
    May 4th, 2010 at 3:31 PM

    I would like to add my voice to the fans of lunapads, lunapanties, and diva cups… I use them all!

    However, in the interest of full disclosure I will give both the pros and the cons of these products for me.

    My background…. I have been using luna everything for the past 3 years and I am someone who has EXTREMELY heavy periods.

    Pros
    - lunapads are pretty!
    - brand new lunapads are so soft, I wanna wear them even when I don’t have my period
    - I used to get extremely painful rashes from the chemicals in the disposables…. these are gone forever!
    - I feel good about not filling up the landfills
    - They save me money!

    Cons (for me the cons only apply to the really heavy days of my period… the rest of the time I am 100% happy with luna anything!)
    - My period will leak through a pad with 2 liners within a couple of hours on the heavy days….
    - When I am wearing the super mega pads with a couple of liners for my heavy days, I do have a unibum!
    - To avoid the unibum and/or changing pads every hour I will usually wear the diva cup with a lunapad…. I am really not a person who ever liked tampons, so I do find the diva cup a bit awkward to use and sometimes it seems like my already painful cramps get worse when I wear the diva cup
    - rinsing the pads before throwing them in the wash is a bit more work than simply throwing something in the garbage…but not that much more

    Despite my difficulties on the heavy days, I still believe reusable menstrual products are sooooooooo worth it and I have probably only used 3 disposable pads/tampons in the past 3 years! I will never go back to that stuff!

    To the original author, I really hope you try lunapads and lunapanties, I think you would be pleasantly surprised!

  • Heidi
    May 4th, 2010 at 3:37 PM

    oh and I forgot to mention…. lunapads do not smell bad… unlike regular pads which smell horrible after you wear them for a few hours!

  • Lee
    May 4th, 2010 at 4:43 PM

    If you love pads you should check out ETSY, which has designs to fit every personality!! Strips, plaids, and dots! Some with cases and some pack as kits! Really fun and joyful. : )

    http://www.etsy.com/search_results.php?search_query=period+pads&search_type=handmade

  • Naomi Zeveloff
    May 4th, 2010 at 9:23 PM

    The DivaCup is a godsend. It’s not only better for the environment, but it’s better for your body. No more icky tampon chemicals being shoved up there. Can’t get the hang of LunaPads.

  • Elly D.
    May 5th, 2010 at 4:33 PM

    So someone tell me, when you take this Lunapad off and is drenched in menstral flow, where are you rinsing this off or do you just toss it in the washing machine? If you are in a public bathroom and you need to change the liner, where are you putting this piece of hygene while replacing it? Now about the Diva Cup, during a heavy flow, are you popping that out, running to the sink (Yuck) and rinsing this out and placing it back in? You can’t mean you just empty the container and put it back in.
    Sounds like there is a need to sterilize something here.
    Most of all, this article certainly has brought us all together in the name of WOMANHOOD.
    My mother told me at 9 years old that when I was a big girl, I was going to have a period. Now I thought a period was how you ended a sentence. Maybe she was right.

  • suzanne (aka Lunagal)
    May 6th, 2010 at 10:39 AM

    Elly D: Good questions. TMI to reply in a comment, so may I suggest you go to this link for answers to these questions (and more!) http://lunapads.com/tips-and-advice. Check out our videos too.
    While reusable menstrual products are designed to be portable, it is worth mentioning that many women only use them in the privacy of their home.

  • Ozarkquilter
    May 6th, 2010 at 4:46 PM

    One day, after the humiliating experience of bleeding through a thick, paper and plastic overnight store bought pad + tampon combo (while at work, I might add) I went on a quest to find something better. Lunapads, the Diva Cup and VvSkiVvy’s have been a God send. I admit, the Diva Cup was wierd at first, but after enduring years of tampons that either dried me out, or leaked, the Cup is a welcome reprieve. Lunapads become softer with every washing, and I even found a pattern on line to sew my own and sew some for charities in Africa. The VvSkiVvy’s give me the peace of mind that I won’t have another bleed through at work. My ONLY regret is not finding these products sooner. I thank all the women out there who made these products possible!!!!

  • Wehaf
    May 6th, 2010 at 6:02 PM

    To baldly state that in “Native American culture, where women retreated to a menstrual hut once a month”, as if there were a single monolithic Native American culture is not only ignorant but insulting.

  • Jana
    May 7th, 2010 at 11:09 AM

    Elly D:

    First, regarding leakage, I do actually use the diva cup (and my MeLuna cup, from Germany), for this also. I have some mild stress incontinence and the cup, when inserted, pushes against the walls of the vagina in such a way that it puts just a teensy bit of pressure on the urethra…which seems to do WONDERS for keeping the urethra from dribbling!

    Second, regarding changing of pads. Most sellers (I buy from Etsy, mostly) also offer small polyurethane-laminated bags that zip shut with a plastic zipper, that you put the used pad into, zip shut, and take home in your purse. They don’t leak, they’re suuuuuuuper cute, and you can just unzip, drop the pad into the washer, and then drop the bag in too!

    Third, about emptying the cup in a public restroom: If the cup has to be changed while you’re in a bathroom stall, you have a few options…#1, pull up your pants/panties and go rinse it in the sink. I personally would NEVER do that but I know some would. Second, wipe it with clean toilet paper and reinsert. Seems gross, but there’s nothing about that toilet paper that is any worse than the tampons most women use! Third, keep a small bottle of water to rinse it with, in your purse. I’ve done that for my last few cycles (got a $1 walmart travel-size soap bottle) and I just pull it out, hold the thing over the toilet between my legs, squirt water on it, reinsert, and then refill the bottle at the sink when I wash my hands. It’s even useful for rinsing off any bits of blood that end up on my fingers!

    Regarding sterilizing, it is fine to just use it all cycle and then sterilize after your period is over, but some women do sterilize every day. For my first few cycles with a cup, I alternated soaking it in peroxide one day, boiling it the next, repeat ad infinum but recently I’ve been comfortable just doing one big cleaning at the end of the cycle.

  • Faith
    May 7th, 2010 at 4:25 PM

    Amy,

    A fishy smell is a sign of infection (BV), as both cloth pads and menstrual cups are more hygienic they don’t cause these infections, and there’s less odour than disposable products.

    I too am a professional woman.
    In fact I work in sexual health, so having bad odour as a result of my menstrual products would be a double blow!

    These products are just as suitable for heavy flow as their disposable cousins, menstrual cups are the best option for women with heavy flow. Cups hold more flow than tampons and pads combined, have light suction, and can significantly lessen menstrual flow, so don’t leak like tampons or pads do. In April the Journal of Obstetrics & Gynaecology even published a study to confirm this.

    I suffer from hyper-menorrhagia.
    I have to take medication to avoid losing dangerous amounts of blood it’s so heavy, and even with the most absorbent tampons and pads I would leak through both, as well as my clothing, within quarter of an hour – with menstrual cups I don’t leak. If they don’t ‘overflow’ for me, they wouldn’t for you…although if you ever do try them I do recommend against Divacup as they are a long and firm cup, other brands are better for first-timers.

    I deal with a lot of women who suffer their periods, from menstrual cramps and chronic infections, through to generally finding periods inconvenient or uncomfortable – reusable options do make a huge difference to both health and their attitude towards their periods, if only they weren’t so hung-up on outdated ideas about menstruation that put them off using them.

    Opinions are fine, but they can effect others attitudes, and so opinions shouldn’t be based on ignorance, or wilful ignorance.

    I’d like to share on here a good little article on Scarleteen [premier sex education site] about washable sanitary pads; Eight Myths About Washable Menstrual Pads Dispelled – http://www.scarleteen.com/article/pink/eight_myths_about_washable_menstrual_pads_dispelled

    Scarleteen also have a good article on menstrual cups; What Are Menstrual Cups? – http://www.scarleteen.com/article/body/what_are_menstrual_cups

    @ Elly D.
    Cloth pads are just as soaked as disposables, you can rinse or just toss straight in the wash, and in public bathrooms you pop into a bag, just as you would with disposables when there is no bin available. Cups rarely have to be emptied in public toilets, but if they do you can wash in the sink (you wash your hands in there, why not a cup?), you can rinse with bottled water over the toilet, or wipe off. You don’t sterilize tampons do you? Cups can be sterilized, but they’re just as sanitary as disposable tampons when washed with soap and water. Even with just a quick wipe they’re not as sanitary going in, but are still more hygienic than tampons.

  • Janine
    May 12th, 2010 at 12:55 PM

    Yikes! I have a few pairs of Lunapanties and I LOVE them! They are so comfy and convenient during my period, but they are awesome during pregnancy too! And my Diva Cup! I can’t say enough good things about it. I’ve saved hundreds of dollars on period supplies, and my period is a breeze now! I hardly even notice it. To each there own, but I think cloth pads and cups are green, economical, and most importantly soooo comfy!

  • Margaret
    May 12th, 2010 at 1:02 PM

    I also love Lunapads. The nasty plastic and bleached cotton pads I used to wear were so uncomfortable… the adhesive used to give me a rash in my bikini area every month. Not pleasant at all. I love the soft cotton feel of lunapads, plus it makes me feel good knowing that I am doing something good for the planet. It’s cheaper and I never have to buy pads or tampons at the grocery store.

    I’m still learning the art of insertion and removal of the Divacup, but I think it’s something worth learning. It’s WAY more comfortable than tampons. I find it tricky to remove, but apparently, it gets easier. Reusable menstrual products are AWESOME.

  • Märia
    May 12th, 2010 at 1:05 PM

    I am an especially heavy bleeder and would always go through 20-30 tampons and 10 or so pads each period (and we’re talking the jumbo size, yuck). It was definitely adding up and it always felt like I was wearing a diaper. I tried Lunapads and did not care for them since they always leaked. I would use the DivaCup, but they are not recommended for women with IUDs. I tried a few other brands, including Sckoons NoLeak Pads. LOVE them. Super comfortable and not bulky. I switched about a year ago and I doubt I’ll ever go back. I didn’t even remotely believe how everyone said they gave you lighter periods, but they really did. Give them a try. BTW, The environment is just a bonus, it really was about the comfort and cost.

  • Isabel
    May 12th, 2010 at 1:08 PM

    So, this attaraceted my attention because it is about Lunapads, and although I share the opinion many of the posters above have, i’m goign to elaborate on something else.

    I think you’ve done a very poor job at introducing your new term of “beige products”. This is not just because the choice is largely personal, without showing or indicating which of your personal opinions influenced the negative outlook of “looks like were out of luck ladies”

    You have not said wether “Beige” products are beige because they fail as a product, or because they fail at being green. I am aware that in the world of green products, some are better then others, and have been looking for something that distinguishes them. I am also someone that gets somewhat annoyed when I see “all natural” cleaners containing borax, that neglect to remind people that they are not save to put in your mouth. Just because something is natural based, doesn’t mean its safe and non toxic.

    p.s. Peat moss was another thing used by some Native Americans, to absorb in both diapers and for monthly flow.

  • Melissa
    May 12th, 2010 at 1:25 PM

    I bought my divacup and liners from Lunapads as a present to myself for my 40th birthday. I am now coming up on 42 in the next month, and I only wish I had been brave enough to try these when I first heard of them!! The divacup is absolutely the best thing ever. I couldn’t wear tampons because they dried me out, and the string bothered me. I hated pads because I always got a rash by the end, and since I have a very heavy flow, I almost always made a mess at night.

    In the past two years, I haven’t made a mess even once! I wash my liners with the rest of my laundry and dry them in the sun. I am so happy I wish I could tell every woman to abandon the artificial products they sell in stores. The cup is a Goddess-Send for sure!!! It makes wearing just a little thin liner not only possible, but absolutely secure in my experience!

    For my 42nd, I am thinking about buying a pair of luna panties and maybe one of their soft, inviting looking bed pads.

    And actually, I am a proud Granola — I loved a Granola so much I married him! :)

  • Kay Em
    May 12th, 2010 at 2:05 PM

    Just one more voice chiming in on what these ladies have said so eloquently. Love Lunapads. Love Lunapanties. Love the DivaCup. This post definitely missed the mark.

  • SarahB
    May 12th, 2010 at 2:06 PM

    I. LOVE. CLOTH. PADS. I can’t say enough good about them!!! I have never tried Lunapanties, but I have been using Lunapads for about 4 years now. Once I discovered them, I actually felt *angry* that no one had ever told me this was an option. Plastic pads are flat-out NASTY. Besides the chemical and landfill issues, the fact of the matter is they feel DISGUSTING. They are hot, sticky, sweaty, crinkly, cause a rash, and irritate my asthma!!! And the SMELL…. oh that smell of a dirty plastic pad makes me sick to my stomach! Do you know how WONDERFUL cotton fleece feels against your soft skin down there??? And the smell of menstrual blood in clean cotton doesn’t turn my stomach. You may think I’m a freak for saying this, and if so, then so be it, but I actually LIKE the smell. It’s earthy and… womanly somehow. I used to see my period as an awful hassle that I was forced to deal with, but now I actually — yes I’m going to say it! — LOOK FORWARD TO IT. My periods used to be EXTREMELY heavy and I had crippling cramps, but ever since I quit using the chemical-filled plastic pads, my flow lightened a lot and my cramps are easy to deal with. I would never, ever, ever go back to disposables. I am a cloth pad user for life!!!!

  • Mailie
    May 12th, 2010 at 2:31 PM

    I can’t think of a better product! Cute, Stylish, Great for the environment and HEALTHIER for women!! I love my lunapads, thong liners and diva cup! Not only am I helping the environment but I can use these every month with less cramps and irritation, I am allergic to regular pads and tampons because of the chemicals in them and the “fabric” they use. Plus they come in so many cool designs, you can choose favorite colors and styles to fit your personality and budget, and the Diva cup is sooo much more comfortable than a tampon, it doesn’t dry you out and doesn’t ride so high that it causes cramping. Speaking of budget did you check out their prices? I save over $60 a month now that I use reusable pads, they might be a little more upfront but the savings is substantial! I love Lunapads and recommend them to everyone and have turned a lot of people into reusable pad users and every one of them can’t believe the difference in comfort.

    You BOMBED on this one ecosalon, maybe your the one who is going “beige” not being able to think out of the box or try something before condemning it to the trash basket. I know who I won’t be going to for my green referrals anymore. LUNAPADS ROCK!!

  • Lor
    May 12th, 2010 at 2:58 PM

    I must agree, the term Beige has not been clarifed even when the editor posted it still remains unclear to me why a product would be labled beige, just because someone who never tried it has the opinion it would be bad? I am totally open for women to have their own opinon and choose what works for them not everything is right for everyone! At the same time when I read a column, even an opinion column, I expect that the person writing the column has tried the product and thus has something to base the opinion on. News or opinion it would be my expectation that at minimun the columnist would have taken the time to try a product before either bashing or reccomending it. Those who have not tried a product are truly still entitled to thier opinoin, but I would not appreciate a columnist who reccomended a product that they had never tired nor do I appreciate a normally very informative column not taking the time to try a product for themselves before posting about it.

  • Mallory
    May 12th, 2010 at 3:31 PM

    Aaaaand this is why I skip periods.

  • Sara Ost
    May 12th, 2010 at 3:36 PM

    Well, Maillie, we’re sorry you think we aren’t able to think outside the box, but you’re certainly entitled to your opinion. ;) Glad the luna products work so well for you – but we would hope that you can accept that there are other green-minded ladies who may not share your opinion, and this doesn’t make them any less fantastic.

    If you are going to stop reading all of our reviews entirely because we happen to take a different opinion on just one product you like, and clearly state it as opinion from a single individual, while allowing a completely transparent and open forum for disagreement publicly on our site – which is free to read and use – then that’s OK with us. 100% satisfaction or agreement is an impossible standard we could never live up to. Since you don’t want to read EcoSalon anymore based on Amy’s opinion of a product, you might try out thedailygreen.com, greenopia.com or EWG – they provide green product reviews, too! Best of luck finding a site you enjoy.

  • Leigh
    May 12th, 2010 at 3:51 PM

    I stumbled across Lunapads/Lunapanties by accident when I was shopping for environmentally friendly pads/tampons. I’d been using Always pads ever since they were invented, but was starting to wonder if the plastic-like dry-weave was irritating my skin. So I decided to switch to Seventh Generation products instead to see if that helped.

    I went to an online drugstore, narrowed my search to natural feminine products, and then sorted by highest customer rating. I have to shamefacedly admit that when something called Lunapads surfaced near the top of the list, my first thought was, “Yeah, right! I’m so sure I’m going to wear a cloth pad and reuse it!” I’m very pro-environment, but there are two areas where I (used to) draw the line… feminine products and low-flow toilets.

    BUT, after my initial reaction, I started thinking that it made perfect sense! I used to have a *very* heavy period, and in addition to a super tampon and an overnight pad, I would put on my “period shorts” (a tight pair of red gym shorts) and sleep on a towel. So what’s so different from tossing reusable pads in the laundry instead of my period shorts and towels?

    So I bought some Lunapads and one pair of Lunapanties and I really, really like them. They’re soft, they don’t trap moisture the way my Always pads did, and I feel good about what I’m doing (for environmental and health reasons). I’ve already noticed an improvement in the irritation I had been experiencing, so I think my suspicion that it had something to do with the plastic pads may have been correct.

    To be fair, the only downside I’ve found so far is that I think Lunapads can improve the design of the part that snaps underneath your underwear. I plan to submit a design suggestion through their website. I think they’d fit a little better if the ‘snap flaps’ were improved so that the whole pad lays completely flat.

    So… for those who aren’t comfortable wearing them to work or changing them in a public place and having to put the used liners in bags… You may want to consider just wearing these at night, when you’re at home, etc. I don’t go to much trouble with hand washing them. I just put some eco-friendly stain stick on them and toss them in with my regular laundry, (just like when my Always pads leaked onto my underwear). I started out thinking that I’d wear these when I’m at home and use Seventh Generation pads at the office. I’m surprised to find myself wanting to just stick to the Lunapads. I haven’t gotten the nerve to try the Diva Cup yet, so I can’t comment on that. :-)

    If you do give them a try, Amy, I hope you enjoy them! Even if it’s just occasionally. I liked your anecdote about lying to your friends about having your period. Ha!

  • Mailie
    May 12th, 2010 at 6:10 PM

    Reply Sara Ost:

    I don’t mind if others have their opinions, but how am I supposed to trust a site that is OK with posting negatively about a great green product before even trying it? If you try a product and feel that it does not hold up the way it claims, or is grossly inferior to others of the like I could understand saying to try something else or go with a different brand, but a lot of people buy stuff through this site’s opinions and this sites opinions are held very highly by a lot of people and to say that lunapads is not a good product is very upsetting, I tried many different types of reusable products before deciding that lunapads was the way to go, their quality, prices and customer service can’t be beat and if you ever have a problem with ANYTHING they are right on it, plus they actually listen to their customers ideas and are super sweet on the phone when dealing with anything, I mostly have only had idea’s for them and accidentally ordered the wrong size of something which they fixed even though I was the one who messed up.

    Opinions are what help keep people who are trying to go green from ending up with bad products or companies who are selling inferior product from getting ripped off. I do not believe that lunapads deserves a bad rap and saying negative things about them WITHOUT trying their products can make them lose a large customer base just through word of mouth and again with no basis for the opinion in the first place.

    To those who have tried it and don’t like it for whatever reason I would like to know if it was because of the actual product or personal hang ups such as the icky factor, extra effort or not being able to use the product properly, because I have not heard yet of anybody who tried the product and actually had a problem with it, mostly they were problems with themselves and their comfort level with reusable products.

    Just to close I would like to say again that I love diversified people and originality and personal opinions thats what makes us all different and fun but please make sure that before throwing an opinion out there that you are at least educated on a subject and not just throwing random opinions on something that you have not looked into at all.

  • Brook
    May 12th, 2010 at 6:37 PM

    I love Lunapads and Luna panties! They’re saving me money, saving my body from unnecessary upset, and saving the planet, too. They’re really easy to look after – soak and wash, and last for ages (I have some pads that are still going strong after 7 years!). And I love that they are so soft and comforting to wear. This will probably sound weird, but to me, they’re kind of like a little security blanket at a time of the month when I’m not always feeling that chipper!

  • Joann
    May 14th, 2010 at 7:39 AM

    We’ve heard from grown ladies on this topic but would you all like to hear the opinion of a 13 year old?

    My daughter has had to use a panty-liner for about two years because of her pre-pubescent discharge. I brought up the idea of cloth pads in the beginning (I use and love the Diva cup and Luna pads) and she was totally against the idea. Quite grossed out. So I got her the disposables.

    A couple of months ago, I decided to make some more pads and asked her again if she wanted to try them. She cautiously agreed so we went to the fabric store, picked out some cute material, and made some itsy-bitsy liners for her. Then we had to go back for more material because she wanted mini pads for when she started her period.

    She has now had one menstrual cycle and loves them. She tells anyone who asks that she’ll never wear disposables unless she’s too embarrassed to be the oddball (camping with her Girl Scout troop, for instance. She IS 13, after all!). She says they stay in place, don’t stick to her skin or hair, (ouch!) don’t migrate around in her underwear, they smell better, feel better, and, since clean-up consists of tossing them in a small container of water until ready to wash, simple to care for.

    So there you have it from a 13 year old.

  • Amy
    May 15th, 2010 at 1:32 PM

    Hello, I just have to comment. I own Lunapads, Lunapanties and the Diva Cup. I would never ever go back. My mother (a horribly sheltered and embarrassed religious woman) had no idea what to do when I got my period, so she took me to walmart and plopped me in “The Aisle” and said “This is what I use but pick whatever you want” and walked away. From that moment on it was taboo to even talk about my menses. Even though I was having excruciating allergic reactions to the pads and ONLY used tampons when I was competitively swimming in High School and even then I cried because I had an allergic reaction to those also. By the time I was 20 I had resigned myself to excruciating pain and discomfort every menses. A friend of mine was super excited one day and told me she’d stumbled across Lunapads.com and had just gotten her order. She hadn’t started her period yet so all of it was still new so she pulled it all out and let me look at it and touch the DivaCup and think. Now, I was intrigued I’d never ever considered there was cloth pads available! I was sold. Made my first order of an intro kit and a divacup kit and the rest is history. The DivaCup did take some getting used to as I was (and still am) a virgin, but definitely worth it. Thank God I no longer have allergic reactions to my pads and DivaCup and also, that unwanted and unwarranted bikini wax from a flipped adhesive pad? NEVER EVER again! So easy to travel with, if I know i’m going out, pop in my DivaCup and wear a liner just in case but I’ve NEVER had a leak issue! I’m 24 now and so much happier!

  • AussieBeth
    May 25th, 2010 at 8:04 PM

    While I don’t own any Lunapads or Lunapanties, I do think they’re a great idea. I do, however, own a DivaCup and I’m totally in love with it. I bought it about 6 months ago and I wish I’d had one decades ago. I used to dread my period. My grandma always called menstruation “the woman’s curse” and for me it was. It was one week every month of pure living hell. Over the years it got worse. Cramps, bloating, and that general “ughk” feeling that left me just wanting to crawl back into bed with my hot water bottle and sleep til it was over. After switching to the DivaCup, I no longer get cramps or bloating, and even on my heaviest days, I still don’t feel “ughk”. I can even go to work and be cheery on those days! The fact of getting my period when I was away on summer holidays used to reduce me to tears. All happened this year while I was away and no-one was any the wiser for it (except for hubby, of course). I even went swimming and hiking at places with only very basic amenities and had no problems at all. And finally, the biggest selling point for this is – my flow is now much noticeably lighter.
    I can’t sing the praises of DivaCup highly or loudly enough! Don’t knock it til you try it!

  • AussieBeth
    May 25th, 2010 at 8:37 PM

    Should also have mentioned in my previous post that for the first time last week I needed to empty my DC in a public restroom. Simply used my water bottle to rinse it off and then popped it back in. Simple.

    The other bonus that has come from me making the switch has been the smell, or rather, the lack thereof. By the end of a week of using pads and tampons my netherbits had quite a distinct “pong” about them. But the bathroom bin was downright NASTY. Even with the “scented antibacterial bin liner” in it, I only had to walk past the bathroom and I could smell it. Talk about rating a 12 out of 10 on the EWWWW factor scale. But now thanks to my DC, there’s no “stinky bin” at all and my netherbits smell like me and not “manky tampon”.

  • Deann Redmiles
    May 27th, 2010 at 12:58 PM

    I started using cloth pads yrs ago, prior to the big push for ECO friendly products. I’m confused at your tone of the article. Have you tried these liners?
    There’s something that’s empowering and no shunning or embarrassment about washing your pads.. it becomes just something like washing your pants, shirts, and socks, not a big deal, just a part of life.
    How is that “beige” and a “miss” ???
    These are pretty, comfy, soft, no allergic reaction to bad chemicals, and there is a certain amount of I’m a woman, these are mine.
    I bought an assortment of pads for my daughter.
    And pretty little cloth cases she can put them in.
    Not a big deal.
    Blood… it happens. Deal with it. Don’t be worried, scared, or frightened.
    Just deal with it.
    I’m just confused that this made your “beige” report.
    D

  • Deann Redmiles
    May 27th, 2010 at 1:53 PM

    Oh .. I should have added. that sea sponges are an option too. I prefer them and they are easy, cheap, I am heading towards menopause, not sure I want the diva cup purchase at this point..
    but my daughter may.. I’ll look into it.

  • Melanie S
    July 7th, 2010 at 10:55 AM

    I’m willing to offer an unbiased review. The Diva Cup hasn’t been perfect in my case but I have to say that after a few cycles (learning to insert it properly) it turned out to be far superior to tampons and disposible pads. I have very heavy flow, and on my heavy days, I can get by with just a panty liner and the cup for an entire workday. This is not possible with tampons. I do, however, need a backup because I start leaking after a while on those heavy days.

    The reason I stuck with it is because I enjoy being able to insert it before I start (no nasty surprises), can leave it in longer than a tampon and don’t need to worry about having tampons on hand.

    I was leery at first, but this series of comments has convinced me to try luna pads. I’m tired of the irritation I get by the end of my cycle due to the plastic/paper liners I still use.

  • Christine
    July 9th, 2010 at 11:25 PM

    I LOVE my divacup! Even if for some reason it wasn’t any better for the environment, i would still choose it over tampons and pads. I can sleep straight through the night without having to worry about leaking and feeling like I just peed my pants! Most days of my cycle, I can go the whole 12 hours (and longer) without even thinking about it. No one can say that about pads or tampons. I won’t ever be going back to reusables.

  • Cris M
    August 31st, 2010 at 10:37 PM

    I definitely agree that this product is one that should not be knocked. It is eco-positive and I feel better knowing that I’m doing my part. It saves me SO much money, and the pads don’t ruin my underwear like the plastic ones do with their adhesive! The divacup is a lifesaver, I can do an hour of heavy exercise without having to worry about changing a tampon half way through or leakage.

    I think they are worth trying, if they don’t work for you, fine.

  • Jean
    September 8th, 2010 at 11:46 PM

    Quote: “Introducing The Beige Report, where we cover the well-meaning, but unfortunate attempts of eco brands with the best of intentions and the not-so-best of products.” I disagree completely! Lunapanties are awesome!

    I used to struggle through my light but long periods using a combination of pads and tampons. I couldn’t use either all the time; tampons would dry me out (light flow) and then I’d get thrush, and pads gave me a rash. Even trying to juggle between the two as carefully as possible I’d often end up with thrush AND a rash by the time my period was finished.

    In addition, plastic-and-paper pads are uncomfortable, sweaty, give you unexpected waxing experiences, and they smell and are nasty to dispose of, and I don’t like swimming with tampons in as they always seem to “wick” water (and whatever is in the water – eeeew!) up inside.

    I wish I’d known about reusable products years ago. I only found out about them a few years ago from a positive thread on another forum I frequent.

    Menstrual cups are great – they don’t dry you out, they have a bigger capacity than a tampon, they save you a bundle and you never “run out”. They don’t “wick” during swimming. I use Lunapanties as a backup (they’re very comfy and well-made), but I have never leaked during the daytime, just occasionally had a little gunk not quite cleaned away from around the outside during the emptying process. (Something I’m getting better at with practice.) In public bathrooms I just go for the “disabled” stall so a basin is at hand – easy! But in fact you don’t have to empty it every time you go to the bathroom anyway, unlike a tampon – again, there’s no “wicking”. btw, all my friends with heavy flow who’ve made the switch have said a cup is way superior in capacity to a tampon. There are forums for cup users where you can get advice about different makes, different fold techniques, trouble-shooting etc. I found these a great help when getting started – I found I needed to fold my cup inside-out to make it comfortable, a tip I got from a forum.

    I’ve found the cup isn’t so good for me at night – on me it tends to ride up (the cup should sit low on the pelvic floor, not high like a tampon) and then it can leak. It’s not a capacity problem, but one of positioning – must be something about my shape. So I use cloth pads at night. Sooooo much more comfy than disposables, more effective, and no, they’re not hard to wash. I don’t find them any more gross to deal with than a disposable pad. I just fling it over to the basin while I’m on the toilet, give it a quick cold rinse while I’m washing my hands, and then chuck it in the wash. How hard is that?

    My older DD now uses a cup and says she loves it, and my younger DD uses cloth pads. She got interested in them because of all the cute colours and desgns you can get, and once she’d tried them said she’d never go back to paper-and-plastic again as cloth is so much more comfortable.

    The environmental and cost benefits are a great, especially with three women in the house, but we actually made the switch for reasons of health, comfort, effectiveness and convenience. (Yes, we find reusables more convenient!)

    btw Diva Cup and Lunapads aren’t the only option. Lunapads is a great company but if their products don’t fit so well on you or whatever, there are lots of different brands and styles of menstrual cups and cloth pads you can try. Personally I love the Diva Cup and Lunapanties, but my fave pad is a hemp trifold all-in-one pad from Obsidian Star. For more info about different styles, this site is good: http://www.clothpads.org/

  • kukkaberra
    June 30th, 2011 at 6:54 PM

    wow. nevermind that the author doesn’t like lunapads. this article is shockingly misogynist and uninformed. hornets in a jar?!? seriously?