The Green Plate: What Every Meat Eater Should Know About Humane Certifications

A few years ago, on a tour of a small village in Vietnam, we were taken to a small farm compound, where the residents manufactured rice paper wrappers for spring rolls and raised a few farm animals for food. There were chickens clucking around and a few friendly, waddling ducks. There was also an enormous pig housed in a small, concrete enclosure.

As our group approached, the pig rose up on her hind legs, placed her front legs on the ledge of her pen, and looked us all straight in the eyes with a completely charming mixture of intelligence and humor. Without a doubt, that pig was posing. The pen was small, but clean. The pig appeared to have plenty of freedom of movement. The pig was whole, no cropped tail, no sores, nothing amiss. I can’t pretend to know if that pig was a happy pig. But from my limited human perspective, she looked contented.

Every time I think about how we raise animals for food, I think about that expressive pig. That pig represents both my deep ambivalence about eating animals and also what I think of as the ideal way to raise animals for food.

For those of us who do eat meat, who don’t raise our own animals, one at a time, or who cannot afford to pay top dollar to buy direct from a very small farm, that ideal is pretty near unattainable.

For conscious omnivores, who eat meat sparingly and thoughtfully, who avoid meat raised under conditions that we call “factory farming”, what is a reasonable level of animal welfare in farming? And how accurate are our perceptions of what constitutes “good farming”?  Farming is a struggle for farmers. There is a delicate balance between the scale and methods that will allow the farmer to stay in business and earn a living, and letting the animals experience life as naturally as possible.

So what does humane treatment of animals actually look like? Who defines it? And most important, if you’re a meat eater, what is your personal line?

The Humane Society of the United States has been actively documenting the worst abuses of factory farming in a series of undercover investigations. In December, a video showing atrocities at a Smithfield pig breeding facility in Virginia was released. The pigs were kept in gestation crates barely large enough for their bodies for their entire lives, live pigs were thrown in dumpsters, and baby piglets were left to die in manure pits after falling through the slats of the crates that their mothers spent their entire lives in.

Just in time for Thanksgiving, a video documenting the routine mutilation of turkey poults at the nation’s largest turkey hatching facility was released. Fifty percent of the turkeys available in typical grocery stores came from that particular hatchery.

How can you be sure that you are not contributing to such practices? Find out what humane treatment is, study the certifications, and then buy meat that you can feel good about.

At a glance, here are the various certifications, their affiliations, and their logos:

Animal Welfare Approved: Animal Welfare Institute (non-profit)

Humane Farm Animal Care: Humane Society of the United States (non-profit)

Global Animal Partnership: Non-profit, but partially funded by and affiliated with Whole Foods

USDA Organic: Govt agency (the National Organic Program includes animal welfare standards into its rules)

American Humane Certified: The American Humane Association (not-for-profit corporation)

All these standards are summarized here. Download the pdf chart to see a chart of side-by-side comparisons.

It’s a complex issue so here’s my take on it:

Best of the Best:

If you have plenty of money and access to small farms, go for the strictest certification, which in most cases is Animal Welfare Approved. This certification seems to cover mostly very small family farms. Some of the small family farms from which you buy might more than meet the requirements, but they also might know their customers well enough that they don’t become certified. The lesson here is to know your farmer and visit the farm, if you can. In which case, the certification doesn’t even matter.

Next Best:

Humane Farm Animal Care does a great job of writing standards for operations of different sizes and scales. Some of the commonly available mid-sized regional producers are able to meet these standards, so if you buy your food in a grocery store, not direct from farmers, this is the best certification to look for.

The Rest:

Global Animal Partnership has some good standards on important issues, but doesn’t address a lot of issues that need addressing. If Whole Foods is your store, you can see where they are headed with their certification system that rates producers according to a series of steps.

USDA Organic is better than nothing but doesn’t impose many restrictions on how the animals are treated other than those relating to feed, antibiotics, and hormones.

American Humane Certified is the weakest because it isn’t transparent and doesn’t address many issues. Plus, it allows a lot of common practices none of the others do.

In the end, you have to decide what your personal limits are – both budgetary and ethically.

Summary of Major Requirements Per Species by Certification

Chickens:

Growth Hormones – prohibited by all except not addressed by American Humane Certified

Antibiotics – prohibited by all except allowed by American Humane Certified

Outdoor access – minimum access required by USDA Organic, pasture required by Animal Welfare Approved, not required by other certifications. When provided, there are specific requirements laid out by Humane Farm Animal Care

Space – 6 lb. per square foot required by Humane Farm Animal Care, .67 square foot per bird for roosting, plus range space required by Animal Welfare Approved, 6.2 lb. per square foot required by American Humane Certified, no space requirements from other certifications.

Required dark periods for sleep – 6 to 8 hours required by all except no requirements by USDA Organic or Global Animal Partnership

Beak and toe clipping – Prohibited by Humane Farm Animal Care, Animal Welfare Approved, and Global Animal Partnership, unclear whether allowed by others.

Pigs:

Growth Hormones – Prohibited by all except allowed by American Humane Certified

Antibiotics – Prohibited by all except allowed by American Humane Certified for disease treatment only

Outdoor Access – Pasture required by Animal Welfare Approved, access required by USDA Organic, not required by Global Animal Partnership or American Humane Certified, standards for both indoor and outdoor care by Humane Farm Animal Care

Tail Docking – not allowed by Humane Farm Animal Care, Animal Welfare Approved, Global Animal Partnership, allowed by USDA Organic and American Humane Certified

Cows

Growth Hormones – Prohibited by all except allowed by American Humane Certified

Antibiotics – Prohibited by all except allowed by American Humane Certified

Pasture Range Requirements – Pasture raising and finishing required by Animal Welfare Approved, Feedlot and grass allowed by Global Animal Partnership and USDA Organic (minimum pasture requirement), standards for both pasture and grass written by Humane Farm Animal Care, (feedlots allowed) no requirements by American Humane Certified

This is the latest installment in Vanessa Barrington’s weekly column, The Green Plate, on the environmental, social, and political issues related to what and how we eat.

Image: Friends of Family Farmers

Sponsored Content:

DISCUSSION

14 thoughts on “The Green Plate: What Every Meat Eater Should Know About Humane Certifications

  1. Pingback: Fairtrade International: Changing the standard (Sample w/Links and Pictures) « Free2Work

  2. Pingback: When Is Fair Trade Coffee Not Fair Trade? | Homebrewed Theology

  3. Pingback: Fair trade lite: Fair Trade USA moves away from worker co-ops | Greediocracy

  4. Pingback: Fair trade lite: Fair Trade USA moves away from worker co-ops | Grist

  5. Pingback: Food Sense» Blog Archive » Our Eggcellent Guide to Egg-Buying

  6. Humane Farm Animal Care is an independent non profit that is not a part of the Humane Society of the United States or any other organization. Humane Farm Animal Care is endorsed by the Humane Society of the United States but not funded by the Humane Society of the United States or any individual humane organization. We are endorsed by 36 humane organizations. It is important to be accurate and unfortunately, when something is “out there” in cyberspace, if it is inaccurate, it is inaccurate forever. Thank you for your interest in the program.

  7. Thank you so much for recognizing Animal Welfare Approved as the “best of the best” when it comes to humane standards for farm animals. Your article, “What Every Meat Eater Should Know about Humane Certifications,” was obviously well researched and well thought out and we are genuinely appreciative of your analysis. However, we would like to clarify two points you made about our organization and our farms.

    First, we are proud of the fact that our farms come in all sizes. We do indeed have small to midsized operations in the program (many selling direct from the farm, at farmers markets or via CSAs), but we also have many farms that are quite large and farms that cooperate in networks to jointly market their products. Several AWA networks of beef, pork and lamb producers turn quite a volume of product in restaurants and in a mixture of both regional and national retailers.

    Second, while one might assume that AWA products are more expensive than those that are conventionally produced, this is not necessarily the case. We are currently conducting a survey comparing prices of AWA-certified grassfed beef to feedlot, grainfeed beef and have found so far that in the Northeast U.S., of the retailers and farms surveyed, primal cuts of AWA beef were in fact lower in price per pound than conventional grainfed beef.

    I’m sure you agree that grassfed beef with its higher nutrient content is well worth purchasing. Research has shown time and again that meat from animals fed grass diets is higher in beta carotene (Vitamin A), conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), and Omega-3 fatty acids. All of these elements are believed to be crucial in reducing diseases like diabetes, cancer and high blood pressure.

    We hope this has clarified a few key points about the Animal Welfare Approved program. Thank you again for your article.

  8. Pingback: Truth Behind the Labels: How Meat Eaters Can Find Out if Their Dinner Was Really Humanely Raised – Left Blog Feeds- Progressive News

  9. Thanks, Vanessa! Presenting the choices like this is much needed — and I feel, ultimately persuasive to a veggie point of view =)

  10. I think you have a problem with your advertising – a Groupon cupon shows up at the end of the article with a Giant Hamburger on it… maybe you want your ads to be more for the Humane society or other green endeavours.

  11. Vanessa, thanks so much for doing this research. I have been wanting a comparison like this for a long time, but hadn’t gotten around to doing it myself. Great work!

 

Submit a comment:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>